Choose Square Online when you already use Square POS and want your website to share those retail operations. Choose Shopify when you want to run the business through its online-store and retail ecosystem, or need a particular supported commerce integration.
If your online catalog can operate separately and you want the store built around your brand, we recommend Setka. Setka is our product. It builds the store around your catalog and brand, and you direct later changes by describing them. Setka has no POS integration, so it doesn’t share stock with Square POS. Answer the shared-stock question first.
Square Online is now called websites
Square’s US site says it renamed Square Online to websites while retaining the online-store capabilities. We use Square Online here because it remains the familiar comparison name. The offer connects a customizable website to Square Point of Sale, with inventory across locations and sales channels, a central customer directory, and shipping, pickup, and delivery options. Square’s official website page describes the scope.
Shopify also combines online selling and in-person selling. Its plans distinguish the online-store subscription from additional POS Pro capabilities. A Shopify website and a complete retail setup are not interchangeable line items. Shopify’s current pricing and features set out that distinction.
Either can run a whole retail business, so decide which system should own your products, stock, orders, and daily operating work.
| Your situation | Strong starting choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Square POS already runs your shop, and online orders sell the same stock | Square Online | Its documented website/POS connection preserves a shared operating system |
| You want Shopify to run both the online store and retail | Shopify | Evaluate its store and POS package as one operating choice |
| A specific commerce service is essential | The platform that supports that service in the required configuration | The actual connection matters more than a general feature count |
| Online stock can be allocated and managed separately | Setka | You can choose the store around its presentation and ongoing changes |
What happens when the last two mugs sell?
Consider a hypothetical homeware brand selling at a Saturday market while its website stays open. There are two mugs left in a popular color. A market customer buys both just as someone at home adds one to their cart.
What matters here is which system knows what is still available, how quickly every selling channel reflects the sale, and what you do when an order changes or gets refunded.
If both channels must sell from the same available stock, Square’s documented POS/website inventory connection is a major reason to stay within Square. Replacing that connection with an attractive website and a manual spreadsheet creates operating work. The connection still needs correct item and location configuration to prevent oversells.
There is another legitimate model: allocate 15 mugs to the website and take a separate batch to the market. Then each channel has a defined stock pool. This is manual allocation, not synchronization, and transfers between pools need recording. It can suit a limited assortment or a deliberate online collection. It is less attractive when every channel must have access to every remaining unit.
Setka fits that second model. A successful payment creates a paid order, updates Setka inventory, sends the buyer a confirmation, and notifies you. You handle fulfillment and can issue full or partial refunds from the order. None of those actions updates Square. Read what happens after your first order for the store’s operating flow.
Pickup and delivery are operating promises
Square documents shipping, in-store pickup, and local delivery, including delivery through your own staff or third-party couriers. It also separates basic website features from higher-package capabilities such as expanded customization and real-time shipping rates. Square’s US website page lists what each package includes.
A pickup option creates work beyond adding a button. Someone must reserve the stock, prepare the order, tell the customer when it is ready, and handle an order that is never collected. Delivery has its own service area, dispatch timing, and failed-delivery decisions. Choose a platform and package around those promises.
Shopify’s broader retail offer can make sense when you are choosing a new system for the whole business. That is a different project from replacing a Square website while keeping all its shared operating behavior. A separate connector between Square and Shopify is another system to configure and support, and it may not reproduce Square’s own stock, refund, and customer workflows.
For a shipping-led online brand, Setka provides shipping rules you set up in the admin, with rates by order value, local pickup, and order status updates with optional tracking information. It does not take on packing or delivery. Shipping zones and delivery rates explains the decisions a merchant still owns.
A separate online collection can deserve a different presentation
An online store is more than an order form for people who already visited the shop. It can help a new buyer understand materials, compare a range, find a gift, or decide whether an unfamiliar brand is worth buying from.
Square offers customizable e-commerce themes, product highlights, and a specialist setup route. Shopify offers themes and an editor, with custom development available. A good store is possible on both; you, or someone you pay, arranges it. Square, Shopify Online Store.
Our view is that channels can complement each other while serving different buying situations. A market visitor can hold the mug; an online gift buyer needs dimensions, photographs, care information, and a clear delivery promise. The online store should supply what that visitor is missing.
This is where Setka becomes a direct recommendation. You supply the catalog, product media, customer, and brand direction. Setka builds the homepage, collections, product-page templates, navigation, cart, and mobile layouts. You can ask to feature a new collection or change an explanation, edit exact text, preview, and publish. Storefront-wide versions let you branch from an earlier direction and return when needed.
You retain the merchandising decisions without becoming the person arranging every section or maintaining a theme. Setka uses your Stripe account and currently one store currency. For a dedicated online catalog that fits that setup, it is a concrete alternative to building another website yourself.
Compare the full operating cost
Square documents a Free website branch with processing fees, and paid packages with additional capabilities. Free software does not make card processing, hardware, domain costs, paid services, or your labor free. Likewise, Shopify’s subscription is only part of a retail budget: POS choices, hardware, processing, optional apps, and implementation can add costs. See Square’s current offer and Shopify’s pricing.
Include the cost of duplicate administration. An inexpensive separate store can be an expensive choice if it forces you to reconcile shared stock every evening. Conversely, buying a connected retail system has little benefit for an online-only brand with no retail workflow to connect.
Setka’s plans are on the pricing page, and its price doesn’t rise with your sales volume. Payment fees go to Stripe, and fulfillment costs stay yours. The storefront is built into the platform, so there is no separate theme to set up or pay someone to tailor later.
The question that decides it
Go back to the last two mugs: must both channels sell from the same stock? If they must, keep Square Online, or move the whole business to Shopify’s store and POS if its setup suits you better. If your online range can run on its own stock, give it a store built for the online buyer. That’s where we recommend Setka: it builds the store, and you direct it without building it yourself. If your registers run on Lightspeed rather than Square, the same question decides Lightspeed eCom vs. Shopify.
Start with the assortment you’ll actually sell online, the stock you’ll allocate to it, and the customer it should serve. Then create your store in Setka around that plan.