For a US maker who will ship orders themselves, Etsy is the sensible first marketplace, especially when the range spans different kinds of creative products. Amazon Handmade belongs on the shortlist when your work fits its approved maker and category rules and its fulfillment options solve a real operating problem. Personalized products change the choice: Amazon Custom orders must be fulfilled by the seller, so FBA is off the table for them.

Decide for one representative offer, not the whole catalog. A large marketplace audience is not a forecast of orders for your mug, necklace, or print. What decides it is whether the offer qualifies and whether you can deliver it at a profit.

The marketplaces overlap, but their product rules differ

Etsy’s seller policy requires products to meet its creativity standards. It is not a general resale site. How an item was made, designed, selected, or sourced matters, and so do the disclosures that go with it. A shop already selling well there still has to check each new product against those rules.

Amazon Handmade’s US program, checked on 16 October 2026, requires an application and approval. Its listed classifications include hand-altered, hand-designed, handcrafted, repurposed, and upcycled products. Approved sellers classify their products and can create a maker profile explaining their work.

Amazon also limits Handmade to listed categories. Those include Kitchen & Dining, Jewelry & Watches, Artwork, Home, and several other categories; an item outside the list does not qualify for Handmade merely because somebody made it by hand. Amazon’s program page directs unlisted categories toward the broader Amazon store instead.

This is why “Which marketplace is best for handmade?” is too coarse a question. A ceramic mug, a personalized mug, and a downloadable illustration are three offers with different qualification and fulfillment questions. Approval for one program or one product is not approval for the whole range.

Ready-made stock and personalized orders need different promises

Imagine a maker with 40 finished mugs. The stock exists, dimensions and weight are known, and a dispatch promise can be based on work already completed. That is a useful candidate for a controlled marketplace trial.

On Etsy, the maker remains responsible for accurate listings, the stated processing time, and fulfilling orders under the seller policy. On Amazon Handmade, a seller can explore seller fulfillment or the FBA route described by Amazon. FBA adds a separate product-eligibility and cost decision; joining Handmade does not mean every product automatically receives the same fulfillment treatment.

Now change the offer to a mug with a customer’s chosen name. Production starts after the order, and the maker has to receive the personalization, make the piece, check it, and dispatch it. Amazon’s Custom rule is decisive: Custom products must be fulfilled by the seller and cannot be fulfilled through FBA.

Choose Amazon Handmade for this offer only if you are happy to ship it yourself. If the draw was Amazon handling every parcel, that reason is gone for personalized work.

Etsy needs the same production discipline. Set a processing time that covers clarifying details with the customer and the capacity you actually have. A marketplace can take orders faster than you can make mugs, so let your making hours limit what you offer.

Compare the fee layers, not a single percentage

On the item price of a $40 mug, Amazon’s referral fee takes $6.00 and Etsy’s transaction and US processing fees take $4.05, unless an Etsy Offsite Ads charge lands on the order. Etsy is cheaper per order at those rates, but the two fee models have different layers, and a headline percentage hides most of them.

Cost layerEtsy, US scopeAmazon Handmade, US scope
Account or setupA shop setup fee may applyProfessional plan required; first-month payment, then ongoing monthly fee waived for approved Handmade sellers
Listing and selling$0.20 listing charges and renewals; 6.5% transaction feeProgram page states a 15% referral fee or $0.30 per shipped unit, whichever is greater
PaymentsUS Etsy Payments rate is 3% + $0.25 per orderThe program page lists the referral fee as the per-sale charge and states no separate processing rate
AcquisitionEtsy Ads and qualifying Offsite Ads add separate costsAny Amazon advertising you buy is a separate cost
FulfillmentMaking, packing, postage, and fulfillment laborSeller fulfillment or eligible FBA costs; Custom remains seller-fulfilled

The Etsy figures come from its fees and payments policies, checked on 16 October 2026. Its transaction fee includes shipping and gift wrapping. US processing has its own total-sale basis, including applicable tax; do not apply every percentage only to the product price.

Amazon’s program page states that a Professional account normally costs $39.99 per month, with a first-month payment before the ongoing waiver for approved Handmade sellers. The same page says you pay referral fees when you sell: 15% or $0.30 per unit, whichever is greater. It also mentions a “referral-fee waiver” for classified Handmade products without saying what it covers. Plan on the 15% rate: the subscription waiver is clear, and a referral waiver that turns out to apply to you is a bonus.

For Etsy, the worked US mug example shows the effect of listing, transaction, processing, making labor, and Offsite Ads. A channel is worth using when the actual mix of orders covers those costs and pays for the work. A lower selling rate cannot compensate for an offer with insufficient margin or an unworkable dispatch promise.

Two marketplaces share your production capacity

You can consider both marketplaces for qualifying work, but each listing creates another promise to fulfill. The same 40 finished mugs cannot be available as 40 units in each channel without an operating method that prevents overselling.

For a first trial, allocate a small portion of stock to the new channel. For unique pieces, list each piece in one place at a time unless your own verified inventory process can keep availability accurate. For made-to-order work, allocate production slots instead of pretending future capacity is unlimited.

Keep a separate channel record of:

  • revenue and shipping collected;
  • platform charges and advertising;
  • production, packing, postage, and fulfillment costs;
  • time spent listing, answering messages, and managing orders;
  • cancellations, returns, and refunds;
  • the contribution left to cover fixed costs and pay for further work.

This lets you see whether the second marketplace adds worthwhile business or mostly duplicates administration. Do not assume a sales difference reflects marketplace quality when the product selection, stock allocation, or advertising differs between the trials.

The first launch doesn’t need your whole catalog either. Start with the offer you can explain and fulfill best. If it works, expand deliberately instead of creating dozens of weak listings to make the shop look busy.

Your own store can have a third job

We see a marketplace and an owned store as different channels. The marketplace can help a shopper discover a product inside its environment. Your own store can receive independent traffic and explain your collection in the context you choose.

For a mug maker, a hypothetical gift guide for coffee lovers could lead to a collection explaining size, finish, packaging, and delivery. A buyer choosing a one-off gift might never become a repeat buyer. The store can still be a useful destination for the next independently acquired gift shopper.

That argument does not depend on moving an Etsy sale elsewhere. Etsy prohibits diverting an Etsy-initiated transaction, and buyer information is subject to marketing and consent restrictions. Keep your independent acquisition plan distinct from marketplace transactions.

Setka is our product, and we recommend it for that store once you know its job. You write a brief that names the buyer, in this case someone choosing a gift for a coffee lover, and add the mugs with their photos, sizes, and finishes. Setka builds the store around them: homepage, collection pages, product pages, and cart. Checkout, payments through your own Stripe account, and orders run in the same platform, so there is no theme or plugin to keep working. When the next collection arrives, open a page, describe what should change, preview it, and publish. Setka takes no commission or referral fee on those sales, and its price doesn’t rise as they grow; Stripe’s processing fees still apply.

Personalized products, such as a mug with a customer’s chosen name, are coming soon in Setka but aren’t live yet, so start the store with your ready-made pieces. If the same mugs will also sell on a marketplace, tell us at [email protected] how you need stock kept in step: requests go straight to the people building Setka.

Choose the marketplace trial around the product and fulfillment promise you can sustain. If you also have a defined independent audience, prepare a store brief that names that audience, the collection, and the buying questions the store should answer. Then build it in Setka.